Romhacking.net

General Category => Gaming Discussion => Topic started by: Zetshiro on April 22, 2013, 06:16:11 am

Title: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: Zetshiro on April 22, 2013, 06:16:11 am
Well that was a mouth full. :laugh:

Well, I'm usually a huge RPG player, but some of them can really scare me off when it's adapted from an anime, as the game will usually expect you to know quite a lot about the source material (which can hamper my enjoyment by quite a bit).

I'm not particularly interested in watching tons of anime just to get an understanding of quite a few games, so I'll just ask, what are the most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material? I remember playing Slayers (SNES) for a bit and finding it really enjoyable yet the Sailor Moon RPG had me Googling a few things (and just generally feeling a bit left out). I was also slightly interested in the .hack PS2 games, but I'm not really sure what I'm getting myself into.

Thanks! :)
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: FallenAngel2387 on April 22, 2013, 09:47:45 am
Funny enough, Slayers was the first thing that came to mind. Tenchi Muyo(also SFC) would be another, this time strategy/tactics.

They both have something in common. There usually aren't long story arcs, and they tend to more episodic(well there are in Slayers, but it's often broken up with oddball one-off episodes). If Lupin ever had one, it'd probably be the easiest one to get into. The worst I've seen with Lupin, canonically, is an occasional 2 or 3 parter.
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: Lilinda on April 22, 2013, 04:45:44 pm
The Sailor Moon RPG is good enough on its mechanics IMO, but the translation has issues and is basically kind of weeabooed up(And inconsistent). So I guess it's a wash. :P
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: KingMike on April 22, 2013, 06:11:20 pm
You mean stuff just left in Romanized Japanese? :P
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: Lilinda on April 22, 2013, 10:13:04 pm
The Silver Millennium Crystal has like three different names in the game, usually the romanized one is used.

Edit: Plus, people from outside of Japan use japanese suffixes to refer to folks and WHY GOD TELL ME WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: Talbain on April 22, 2013, 11:53:55 pm
Sweet Home?

edit: oh, least enjoyable.  I dunno.  Doesn't really matter.  Samurai Pizza Cats or something.
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: Next Gen Cowboy on April 23, 2013, 12:51:41 am
MegaTen, more specifically Nocturne, as I had no clue it was all based on Novels until much later, if that doesn't count then Parasite Eve.

Least favorite... I have no clue, I'm sure there's some game I didn't like that had source material I didn't know, but I can't be bothered to try and figure it out.
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: Kronus_Arm on April 23, 2013, 08:35:52 am
Enjoyable?

Hmmm... My vote goes for The Adventures of Hourai High. As I recall from Gideon Zhi's notes, it is based from the light novel of basically the same name, though I couldn't find a copy of it on the net but, I do hope someone takes the time to translate it.

I immensely enjoyed the game because of it's humor, interesting plot twists and the club system (which you can gain useful abilities ala FFV).

Oh by the way, I must also ask the translator for this game if there's some gaiden or sequel to this, coz' the ending kinda left me hanging and craving for more. :P
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: eefara on April 23, 2013, 03:06:47 pm
MegaTen, more specifically Nocturne, as I had no clue it was all based on Novels until much later, if that doesn't count then Parasite Eve.

I believe only Megami Tensei I was based off the original Digital Devil Story novels. Everything past that game (correct me if I'm wrong) is, overall, original material.
Title: Re: Most and least enjoyable adapted RPG's without knowing the source material?
Post by: Next Gen Cowboy on April 23, 2013, 04:01:42 pm
I believe only Megami Tensei I was based off the original Digital Devil Story novels. Everything past that game (correct me if I'm wrong) is, overall, original material.

To my knowledge you're absolutely correct. Although I never read the second novel onward, and what I did read was linked to from AGTP if memory serves, I think Gid mentions that it's the case, and I'll take his word on it. So if we don't count that, then it's Parasite Eve, which again is loosely based on source material, I've still yet to read the novel (or find a copy of it).