I enjoyed it more much than Persona 3, probably because I could now play it removed from the "bestest game evar!!1" hype that surrounded that. The battle systems feels much more like a full fledged press turn version and not like the watered down version from P3 (no forced Ai control, yay!). And the battles in general are as finely tuned as ever. The story also had a strong mystery that made you want to continue. I also liked the characters much more. The pacing however was completely terrible. There are way too long segments of nothing but boring daily life, often with not even Social Links to progress on. IIRC P3 had one chapter including a dungeon for every month. P4 has segments with 3 months of nothing happening. At those times it's really really painful to keep playing. The director of this game needs to be fired, but I guess this slice of life shit is what the fanboys crave, and in their mind the boredom adds to the "realism".